Possible conflict with outline-magic

Possible conflict with outline-magic

[John Haman]

Hello, I would like to use the outline-magic package to cycle headings 
in outline-mode. I installed outline magic, and put the recommended 
configuration in my init file.

(use-package outline-magic
   :ensure t
   :config
   (add-hook 'outline-mode-hook
             (lambda ()
               (require 'outline-cycle))))

The package works great! I can easily cycle visibility of headings in 
outline-mode with TAB. No further configuration.

After installing outline-magic, my org-capture stopped working. I have a 
very benign capture configuration.

(use-package org-capture
   :after org
   :hook
   (org-capture-mode . evil-insert-state)
   :custom
   (org-capture-templates ... <all my templates> ... ))

When I call org-capture now, I get an error:

Template key:
File mode specification error: (file-missing Cannot open load file No 
such file or directory outline-cycle)
org-capture: Capture abort: (file-missing Cannot open load file No such 
file or directory outline-cycle)

How do I prevent this strange interaction between outline-magic and 
org-capture?

What I tried:

- Loading outline-magic after org-mode.

- Deleting Elpa folder and reinstalling all packages.

No luck so far.

(Note: I cannot switch from outline-mode to markdown-mode because 
markdown-mode has fontificiation issues on the files I edit)

Thanks all, any help here is greatly appreciated.

John

Re: Possible conflict with outline-magic

[John Haman]

Well, I was able to fix my issue using the configuration on EmacsWiki

(use-package outline-magic
   :ensure t
   :config
   (eval-after-load 'outline
     '(progn
        (require 'outline-magic)
        (define-key outline-minor-mode-map (kbd "<C-tab>") 
'outline-cycle))))

But I'm not sure why this should work while the configuration that comes 
with outline-magic interacts with org-capture.

-John

On 9/12/20 9:52 AM, John Haman wrote:
> Hello, I would like to use the outline-magic package to cycle headings 
> in outline-mode. I installed outline magic, and put the recommended 
> configuration in my init file.
>
> (use-package outline-magic
>   :ensure t
>   :config
>   (add-hook 'outline-mode-hook
>             (lambda ()
>               (require 'outline-cycle))))
>
> The package works great! I can easily cycle visibility of headings in 
> outline-mode with TAB. No further configuration.
>
> After installing outline-magic, my org-capture stopped working. I have 
> a very benign capture configuration.
>
> (use-package org-capture
>   :after org
>   :hook
>   (org-capture-mode . evil-insert-state)
>   :custom
>   (org-capture-templates ... <all my templates> ... ))
>
> When I call org-capture now, I get an error:
>
> Template key:
> File mode specification error: (file-missing Cannot open load file No 
> such file or directory outline-cycle)
> org-capture: Capture abort: (file-missing Cannot open load file No 
> such file or directory outline-cycle)
>
> How do I prevent this strange interaction between outline-magic and 
> org-capture?
>
> What I tried:
>
> - Loading outline-magic after org-mode.
>
> - Deleting Elpa folder and reinstalling all packages.
>
> No luck so far.
>
> (Note: I cannot switch from outline-mode to markdown-mode because 
> markdown-mode has fontificiation issues on the files I edit)
>
> Thanks all, any help here is greatly appreciated.
>
> John
>

Re: Possible conflict with outline-magic

[Ihor Radchenko]

> But I'm not sure why this should work while the configuration that comes 
> with outline-magic interacts with org-capture.

org-mode is derived mode based on outline-mode. "Derived" in Emacs means
that outline-mode-hook also runs in org-mode.

org-capture-mode is derived mode based on org-mode. So, it runs
org-capture-mode-hook, org-mode-hook, and outline-mode-hook.

The first version of the code you used is not valid:

>> (use-package outline-magic
>> ...
>>               (require 'outline-cycle))))

There is no 'outline-cycle feature provided by outline-magic package.
Hence, when you run org-capture, it is trying to run outline-magic-hook
that runs (require 'outline-cycle), which does not exist. Hence, the
error you observed.

I believe that the code you used (and copied from Example section of
outline-magic package) is carried out from the times when outline-magic
was called outline-cycle. You might consider reporting this as a bug in
outline-magic github page.

Best,
Ihor



John Haman <mail@johnhaman.org> writes:

> Well, I was able to fix my issue using the configuration on EmacsWiki
>
> (use-package outline-magic
>    :ensure t
>    :config
>    (eval-after-load 'outline
>      '(progn
>         (require 'outline-magic)
>         (define-key outline-minor-mode-map (kbd "<C-tab>") 
> 'outline-cycle))))
>
> But I'm not sure why this should work while the configuration that comes 
> with outline-magic interacts with org-capture.
>
> -John
>
> On 9/12/20 9:52 AM, John Haman wrote:
>> Hello, I would like to use the outline-magic package to cycle headings 
>> in outline-mode. I installed outline magic, and put the recommended 
>> configuration in my init file.
>>
>> (use-package outline-magic
>>   :ensure t
>>   :config
>>   (add-hook 'outline-mode-hook
>>             (lambda ()
>>               (require 'outline-cycle))))
>>
>> The package works great! I can easily cycle visibility of headings in 
>> outline-mode with TAB. No further configuration.
>>
>> After installing outline-magic, my org-capture stopped working. I have 
>> a very benign capture configuration.
>>
>> (use-package org-capture
>>   :after org
>>   :hook
>>   (org-capture-mode . evil-insert-state)
>>   :custom
>>   (org-capture-templates ... <all my templates> ... ))
>>
>> When I call org-capture now, I get an error:
>>
>> Template key:
>> File mode specification error: (file-missing Cannot open load file No 
>> such file or directory outline-cycle)
>> org-capture: Capture abort: (file-missing Cannot open load file No 
>> such file or directory outline-cycle)
>>
>> How do I prevent this strange interaction between outline-magic and 
>> org-capture?
>>
>> What I tried:
>>
>> - Loading outline-magic after org-mode.
>>
>> - Deleting Elpa folder and reinstalling all packages.
>>
>> No luck so far.
>>
>> (Note: I cannot switch from outline-mode to markdown-mode because 
>> markdown-mode has fontificiation issues on the files I edit)
>>
>> Thanks all, any help here is greatly appreciated.
>>
>> John
>>