Re: problems with templates and ID in properties

[Uwe Brauer <oub@mat.ucm.es>]

>>> "IR" == Ihor Radchenko <yantar92@posteo.net> writes:

> Uwe Brauer via "General discussions about Org-mode."
> <emacs-orgmode@gnu.org> writes:

>>> Uwe Brauer <oub@mat.ucm.es> writes:
>> 
>> Thanks for you answer
>>> This is expected. As per `org-capture-templates' docstring, "entry"
>>> capture type inserts top-level entries into files:
>> 
>>> entry       an Org node, with a headline.  Will be filed
>>> as the child of the target entry or as a
>>> top-level entry.  Its default template is:
>>> "* %?
>> 
>> So that cannot be changed, do I understand correctly.

> It might be changed. Currently, we mimic the behavior of
> org-yank-subtree, so that we always insert captured entry under the
> correct level regardless of the capture target. For example, when you
> use OLP, the level will be adjusted.

> May you please explain more why you need to use level 2 heading specifically?


Sure. I use this template for extracting from emails sent by my students
their names and email addresses to have entries like this
--8<---------------cut here---------------start------------->8---
* Grupos                                                           :noexport:
     :PROPERTIES:
     :EXPORT_OPTIONS: num:t
     :COLUMNS:  %10GRP(Grupos) %10HOJA(Hoja Nr) %10EJ(Ejericio Nr) %17DATE(Date) %7STATUS(Status){X/}
     :ID:       Grupos
     :END:

** !!TODO!! G1 <2023-01-24 12:51> :Annu24: Paul New
   :PROPERTIES:
   :ID:       0da9c464-74a1-4153-b957-72e6b562bb0a
   :Link:     [[gnus:nnimap+UCMgmail:INBOX#CAMZEOZ24BUfHRj3_XaF6kxyPBZ4vY4G=Qvb2iuJz4zENAPOFsw@mail.gmail.com][Email from User1: [Annu23] formar Grupo]]
   :Email:    user1@gmail.com
   :Grp:      Gr1
   :Usuario1: User1
   :Email1:   user1@gmail.com
   :Usuario2: User2
   :Email2:   user2@gmail.com
   :H2:       1 (Función implícita)
   :P2:       25
   :STHAB2:   [ ]
   :StEnv2:   [ ]
   :H4:       2 (Convergencia adaptativo)
   :P4:       50
   :STHAB4:   [X]
   :StEnv4:   [X]
   :End:
** !!TODO!! G2 <2023-01-29 19:11> :Annu24: John Doe
   :PROPERTIES:
   :ID:       57aed14b-6790-43de-9440-af082d555800
   :Link:     [[gnus:nnimap+UCMgmail:INBOX#CANpraWwp91vH=-N2y3A5pm7hwuRt-Qzq_Gy7ZyYp7jc5uZ=4AA@mail.gmail.com][Email from User2: [Annu23] formar Grupo]]
   :Email:    user3@gmail.com
   :Grp:      Gr2
   :Usuario1: User3
   :Email1:   user3@gmail.com
   :Usuario2: User4
   :Email2:   user@gmail.com
   :H1:       4 (Método \theta)
   :P1:       10
   :STHAB1:   [X]
   :StEnv1:   [X]
   :SUMMARY:  ok
   :H2:       1
   :P2:       10
   :STHAB2:   [X]
   :StEnv2:   [X]
   :H5:       6 (Func Ampli RK)
   :P5:       5
   :STHAB5:   [X]
   :StEnv5:   [X]
   :End:
--8<---------------cut here---------------end--------------->8---

** Sheet     
so I can use now columnview to generate a table
--8<---------------cut here---------------start------------->8---


#+TBLNAME: sheets
#+BEGIN: columnview :maxlevel 2  :skip-empty-rows t  :indent nil :hlines 2  :format "%10Grp(Grupo) %7H1(Hoja1-Ej) %10P1(\%) %7H2(Hoja2-Ej) %10P2(\%) %7H3(Hoja3-Ej) %10P3(\%)  %7H4(Hoja4-Ej)  %10P4(\%) %7H5(Hoja5-Ej) %10P5(\%) %7H6(Hoja6-Ej) %10P6(\%)"
| <10>  | <7>          | <10> | <7>                   | <10> | <7>      | <10> | <7>                         | <10> | <7>               | <10> | <7>      | <10> |
| Grupo | Hoja1-Ej     | %    | Hoja2-Ej              |    % | Hoja3-Ej | %    | Hoja4-Ej                    | %    | Hoja5-Ej          | %    | Hoja6-Ej | %    |
|-------+--------------+------+-----------------------+------+----------+------+-----------------------------+------+-------------------+------+----------+------|
| Gr1   |              |      | 1 (Función implícita) |   25 |          |      | 2 (Convergencia adaptativo) | 50   |                   |      |          |      |
|-------+--------------+------+-----------------------+------+----------+------+-----------------------------+------+-------------------+------+----------+------|
| Gr2   | 4 (Método \theta) | 10   | 1                     |   10 |          |      |                             |      | 6 (Func Ampli RK) | 5    |          |      |
#+END:

--8<---------------cut here---------------end--------------->8---

That however only works if the entries have level **

It my workflow now clearer?

>> What command/variable could org-mode force to have always an UUID in the
>> ID property?

> `org-id-method' I think.

This variable sets the format, but as far as I can see, is not
reasonable for adding an ID.

regards

-- 
I strongly condemn Hamas heinous despicable pogroms/atrocities on Israel
I strongly condemn Putin's war of aggression against Ukraine.
I support to deliver weapons to Ukraine's military. 
I support the EU and NATO membership of Ukraine.