emacs-orgmode@gnu.org archives
 help / color / mirror / code / Atom feed
From: Ihor Radchenko <yantar92@gmail.com>
To: Noboru Ota <me@nobiot.com>
Cc: emacs-orgmode@gnu.org
Subject: Re: Introducing Org-transclusion
Date: Sun, 14 Nov 2021 17:35:01 +0800	[thread overview]
Message-ID: <87czn3gjwa.fsf@localhost> (raw)
In-Reply-To: <878rxrdu46.fsf@localhost>

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 1201 bytes --]

Ihor Radchenko <yantar92@gmail.com> writes:

>> 4. This file does not seem realistic for me as a user who use Emacs for
>> writing -- but I see this sort of testing can be useful for avoiding
>> potential issues.  How important do you think it is to tackle this type
>> of "hypothetical" issues as a package developer?  It's a question of
>> priority for me.  I do not feel that I have sufficient knowledge and
>> skill set to tackle it right now; if the priority is not so high, I think
>> I would leave it (for now, but this "for now" would be for a long time).
>> If priority is high, I would need to ask for some help with even framing
>> the problem so that we can somehow tackle it.
>
> It is not very important. I did not think about recursive issue when
> created the file. Mostly wanted to create a random large file.

I tried to create a more realistic large file. AFAIU, there should be no
recursion issue this time. M-x org-transclusion-add-all is very slow in
the attached file. Same for saving file after edits (even if edits are
outside the transcluded parts).

For reference, overlays generally start to be an issue from >10k
overlays. This file just have a few hundreds.

Best,
Ihor


[-- Attachment #2: huge.org --]
[-- Type: application/vnd.lotus-organizer, Size: 11718 bytes --]

*** this is a headline with id a
:PROPERTIES:
:ID:       d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22
:END:
**** Subheading
With text in it asdlkj
The headline will be transcluded many times below.
* Everything
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 

** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
** top-level
#+transclude: [[id:d7a2303a-712f-4cf4-a4d1-f8fa8daebf22][this is a headline with id]] 
* another top

  reply	other threads:[~2021-11-14  9:34 UTC|newest]

Thread overview: 36+ messages / expand[flat|nested]  mbox.gz  Atom feed  top
2021-10-30 11:51 Noboru Ota
2021-10-30 12:31 ` Juan Manuel Macías
2021-11-01  9:17   ` Noboru Ota
2021-10-30 13:59 ` Ihor Radchenko
2021-11-01  9:11   ` Noboru Ota
2021-11-01 13:24     ` Ihor Radchenko
2021-11-06 10:43       ` Noboru Ota
2021-11-08 15:07         ` Ihor Radchenko
2021-11-10 21:09           ` Noboru Ota
2021-11-14  8:22             ` Ihor Radchenko
2021-11-14  9:35               ` Ihor Radchenko [this message]
2021-11-01 20:07     ` Thomas Paulsen
2021-11-01 21:01       ` Noboru Ota
2021-11-02  5:17     ` Timothy
2021-11-05 19:53       ` Noboru Ota
2021-11-05 21:56         ` Tim Cross
2021-11-05 23:20           ` Timothy
2021-11-06 10:14             ` Noboru Ota
2021-11-06 10:22               ` Tim Cross
2021-11-06 11:49                 ` Noboru Ota
2021-11-05 17:11 ` Uwe Brauer
2021-11-05 19:24   ` Noboru Ota
2021-11-05 20:15     ` Uwe Brauer
2021-11-05 23:02       ` Noboru Ota
2021-11-06 14:01         ` Uwe Brauer
2021-11-06 14:25         ` Ihor Radchenko
2021-11-06 14:54           ` Noboru Ota
2021-11-06 15:49             ` Uwe Brauer
2021-11-07  7:34               ` Ihor Radchenko
2021-11-07  8:07                 ` Uwe Brauer
2021-11-07  8:30                   ` Ihor Radchenko
2021-11-07 13:25                     ` Uwe Brauer
2021-11-07 13:41                       ` Ihor Radchenko
2021-11-07 13:56                         ` Uwe Brauer
2021-11-05 19:59   ` Noboru Ota
2021-11-05 20:13     ` Uwe Brauer

Reply instructions:

You may reply publicly to this message via plain-text email
using any one of the following methods:

* Save the following mbox file, import it into your mail client,
  and reply-to-all from there: mbox

  Avoid top-posting and favor interleaved quoting:
  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posting_style#Interleaved_style

  List information: https://www.orgmode.org/

* Reply using the --to, --cc, and --in-reply-to
  switches of git-send-email(1):

  git send-email \
    --in-reply-to=87czn3gjwa.fsf@localhost \
    --to=yantar92@gmail.com \
    --cc=emacs-orgmode@gnu.org \
    --cc=me@nobiot.com \
    --subject='Re: Introducing Org-transclusion' \
    /path/to/YOUR_REPLY

  https://kernel.org/pub/software/scm/git/docs/git-send-email.html

* If your mail client supports setting the In-Reply-To header
  via mailto: links, try the mailto: link

Code repositories for project(s) associated with this inbox:

	https://git.savannah.gnu.org/cgit/emacs/org-mode.git

This is a public inbox, see mirroring instructions
for how to clone and mirror all data and code used for this inbox;
as well as URLs for read-only IMAP folder(s) and NNTP newsgroup(s).